Bobby L. Craig


# Abstract This document describes a way to add origin authentication, message integrity, and replay resistance to HTTP REST requests. It is intended to be used over the HTTPS protocol. # Copyright Notice Copyright (c) 2011 Joyent, Inc. and the persons identified as document authors. All rights reserved. Code Components extracted from this document must include MIT License text. # Introduction This protocol is intended to provide a standard way for clients to sign HTTP requests. RFC2617 (HTTP Authentication) defines Basic and Digest authentication mechanisms, and RFC5246 (TLS 1.2) defines client-auth, both of which are widely employed on the Internet today. However, it is common place that the burdens of PKI prevent web service operators from deploying that methodology, and so many fall back to Basic authentication, which has poor security characteristics. Additionally, OAuth provides a fully-specified alternative for authorization of web service requests, but is not (always) ideal for machine to machine communication, as the key acquisition steps (generally) imply a fixed infrastructure that may not make sense to a service provider (e.g., symmetric keys). Several web service providers have invented their own schemes for signing HTTP requests, but to date, none have been placed in the public domain as a standard. This document serves that purpose. There are no techniques in this proposal that are novel beyond previous art, however, this aims to be a simple mechanism for signing these requests. # Signature Authentication Scheme The "signature" authentication scheme is based on the model that the client must authenticate itself with a digital signature produced by either a private asymmetric key (e.g., RSA) or a shared symmetric key (e.g., HMAC). The scheme is parameterized enough such that it is not bound to any particular key type or signing algorithm. However, it does explicitly assume that clients can send an HTTP `Date` header. ## Authorization Header The client is expected to send an Authorization header (as defined in RFC 2617) with the following parameterization: credentials := "Signature" params params := 1#(keyId | algorithm | [headers] | [ext] | signature) digitalSignature := plain-string keyId := "keyId" "=" <"> plain-string <"> algorithm := "algorithm" "=" <"> plain-string <"> headers := "headers" "=" <"> 1#headers-value <"> ext := "ext" "=" <"> plain-string <"> signature := "signature" "=" <"> plain-string <"> headers-value := plain-string plain-string = 1*( %x20-21 / %x23-5B / %x5D-7E ) ### Signature Parameters #### keyId REQUIRED. The `keyId` field is an opaque string that the server can use to look up the component they need to validate the signature. It could be an SSH key fingerprint, an LDAP DN, etc. Management of keys and assignment of `keyId` is out of scope for this document. #### algorithm REQUIRED. The `algorithm` parameter is used if the client and server agree on a non-standard digital signature algorithm. The full list of supported signature mechanisms is listed below. #### headers OPTIONAL. The `headers` parameter is used to specify the list of HTTP headers used to sign the request. If specified, it should be a quoted list of HTTP header names, separated by a single space character. By default, only one HTTP header is signed, which is the `Date` header. Note that the list MUST be specified in the order the values are concatenated together during signing. To include the HTTP request line in the signature calculation, use the special `request-line` value. While this is overloading the definition of `headers` in HTTP linguism, the request-line is defined in RFC 2616, and as the outlier from headers in useful signature calculation, it is deemed simpler to simply use `request-line` than to add a separate parameter for it. #### extensions OPTIONAL. The `extensions` parameter is used to include additional information which is covered by the request. The content and format of the string is out of scope for this document, and expected to be specified by implementors. #### signature REQUIRED. The `signature` parameter is a `Base64` encoded digital signature generated by the client. The client uses the `algorithm` and `headers` request parameters to form a canonicalized `signing string`. This `signing string` is then signed with the key associated with `keyId` and the algorithm corresponding to `algorithm`. The `signature` parameter is then set to the `Base64` encoding of the signature. ### Signing String Composition In order to generate the string that is signed with a key, the client MUST take the values of each HTTP header specified by `headers` in the order they appear. 1. If the header name is not `request-line` then append the lowercased header name followed with an ASCII colon `:` and an ASCII space ` `. 2. If the header name is `request-line` then append the HTTP request line, otherwise append the header value. 3. If value is not the last value then append an ASCII newline `\n`. The string MUST NOT include a trailing ASCII newline. # Example Requests All requests refer to the following request (body omitted): POST /foo HTTP/1.1 Host: Date: Tue, 07 Jun 2011 20:51:35 GMT Content-Type: application/json Content-MD5: h0auK8hnYJKmHTLhKtMTkQ== Content-Length: 123 The "rsa-key-1" keyId refers to a private key known to the client and a public key known to the server. The "hmac-key-1" keyId refers to key known to the client and server. ## Default parameterization The authorization header and signature would be generated as: Authorization: Signature keyId="rsa-key-1",algorithm="rsa-sha256",signature="Base64(RSA-SHA256(signing string))" The client would compose the signing string as: date: Tue, 07 Jun 2011 20:51:35 GMT ## Header List The authorization header and signature would be generated as: Authorization: Signature keyId="rsa-key-1",algorithm="rsa-sha256",headers="request-line date content-type content-md5",signature="Base64(RSA-SHA256(signing string))" The client would compose the signing string as (`+ "\n"` inserted for readability): POST /foo HTTP/1.1 + "\n" date: Tue, 07 Jun 2011 20:51:35 GMT + "\n" content-type: application/json + "\n" content-md5: h0auK8hnYJKmHTLhKtMTkQ== ## Algorithm The authorization header and signature would be generated as: Authorization: Signature keyId="hmac-key-1",algorithm="hmac-sha1",signature="Base64(HMAC-SHA1(signing string))" The client would compose the signing string as: date: Tue, 07 Jun 2011 20:51:35 GMT # Signing Algorithms Currently supported algorithm names are: * rsa-sha1 * rsa-sha256 * rsa-sha512 * dsa-sha1 * hmac-sha1 * hmac-sha256 * hmac-sha512 # Security Considerations ## Default Parameters Note the default parameterization of the `Signature` scheme is only safe if all requests are carried over a secure transport (i.e., TLS). Sending the default scheme over a non-secure transport will leave the request vulnerable to spoofing, tampering, replay/repudiation, and integrity violations (if using the STRIDE threat-modeling methodology). ## Insecure Transports If sending the request over plain HTTP, service providers SHOULD require clients to sign ALL HTTP headers, and the `request-line`. Additionally, service providers SHOULD require `Content-MD5` calculations to be performed to ensure against any tampering from clients. ## Nonces Nonces are out of scope for this document simply because many service providers fail to implement them correctly, or do not adopt security specifications because of the infrastructure complexity. Given the `header` parameterization, a service provider is fully enabled to add nonce semantics into this scheme by using something like an `x-request-nonce` header, and ensuring it is signed with the `Date` header. ## Clock Skew As the default scheme is to sign the `Date` header, service providers SHOULD protect against logged replay attacks by enforcing a clock skew. The server SHOULD be synchronized with NTP, and the recommendation in this specification is to allow 300s of clock skew (in either direction). ## Required Headers to Sign It is out of scope for this document to dictate what headers a service provider will want to enforce, but service providers SHOULD at minimum include the `Date` header. # References ## Normative References * [RFC2616] Hypertext Transfer Protocol -- HTTP/1.1 * [RFC2617] HTTP Authentication: Basic and Digest Access Authentication * [RFC5246] The Transport Layer Security (TLS) Protocol Version 1.2 ## Informative References Name: Mark Cavage (editor) Company: Joyent, Inc. Email: [email protected] URI: # Appendix A - Test Values The following test data uses the RSA (2048b) keys, which we will refer to as `keyId=Test` in the following samples: -----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY----- MIGfMA0GCSqGSIb3DQEBAQUAA4GNADCBiQKBgQDCFENGw33yGihy92pDjZQhl0C3 6rPJj+CvfSC8+q28hxA161QFNUd13wuCTUcq0Qd2qsBe/2hFyc2DCJJg0h1L78+6 Z4UMR7EOcpfdUE9Hf3m/hs+FUR45uBJeDK1HSFHD8bHKD6kv8FPGfJTotc+2xjJw oYi+1hqp1fIekaxsyQIDAQAB -----END PUBLIC KEY----- -----BEGIN RSA PRIVATE KEY----- MIICXgIBAAKBgQDCFENGw33yGihy92pDjZQhl0C36rPJj+CvfSC8+q28hxA161QF NUd13wuCTUcq0Qd2qsBe/2hFyc2DCJJg0h1L78+6Z4UMR7EOcpfdUE9Hf3m/hs+F UR45uBJeDK1HSFHD8bHKD6kv8FPGfJTotc+2xjJwoYi+1hqp1fIekaxsyQIDAQAB AoGBAJR8ZkCUvx5kzv+utdl7T5MnordT1TvoXXJGXK7ZZ+UuvMNUCdN2QPc4sBiA QWvLw1cSKt5DsKZ8UETpYPy8pPYnnDEz2dDYiaew9+xEpubyeW2oH4Zx71wqBtOK kqwrXa/pzdpiucRRjk6vE6YY7EBBs/g7uanVpGibOVAEsqH1AkEA7DkjVH28WDUg f1nqvfn2Kj6CT7nIcE3jGJsZZ7zlZmBmHFDONMLUrXR/Zm3pR5m0tCmBqa5RK95u 412jt1dPIwJBANJT3v8pnkth48bQo/fKel6uEYyboRtA5/uHuHkZ6FQF7OUkGogc mSJluOdc5t6hI1VsLn0QZEjQZMEOWr+wKSMCQQCC4kXJEsHAve77oP6HtG/IiEn7 kpyUXRNvFsDE0czpJJBvL/aRFUJxuRK91jhjC68sA7NsKMGg5OXb5I5Jj36xAkEA gIT7aFOYBFwGgQAQkWNKLvySgKbAZRTeLBacpHMuQdl1DfdntvAyqpAZ0lY0RKmW G6aFKaqQfOXKCyWoUiVknQJAXrlgySFci/2ueKlIE1QqIiLSZ8V8OlpFLRnb1pzI 7U1yQXnTAEFYM560yJlzUpOb1V4cScGd365tiSMvxLOvTA== -----END RSA PRIVATE KEY----- And all examples use this request: POST /foo?param=value&pet=dog HTTP/1.1 Host: Date: Thu, 05 Jan 2012 21:31:40 GMT Content-Type: application/json Content-MD5: Sd/dVLAcvNLSq16eXua5uQ== Content-Length: 18 {"hello": "world"} ### Default The string to sign would be: date: Thu, 05 Jan 2012 21:31:40 GMT The Authorization header would be: Authorization: Signature keyId="Test",algorithm="rsa-sha256",signature="ATp0r26dbMIxOopqw0OfABDT7CKMIoENumuruOtarj8n/97Q3htHFYpH8yOSQk3Z5zh8UxUym6FYTb5+A0Nz3NRsXJibnYi7brE/4tx5But9kkFGzG+xpUmimN4c3TMN7OFH//+r8hBf7BT9/GmHDUVZT2JzWGLZES2xDOUuMtA=" ### All Headers Parameterized to include all headers, the string to sign would be (`+ "\n"` inserted for readability): POST /foo?param=value&pet=dog HTTP/1.1 + "\n" host: + "\n" date: Thu, 05 Jan 2012 21:31:40 GMT + "\n" content-type: application/json + "\n" content-md5: Sd/dVLAcvNLSq16eXua5uQ== + "\n" content-length: 18 The Authorization header would be: Authorization: Signature keyId="Test",algorithm="rsa-sha256",headers="request-line host date content-type content-md5 content-length",signature="H/AaTDkJvLELy4i1RujnKlS6dm8QWiJvEpn9cKRMi49kKF+mohZ15z1r+mF+XiKS5kOOscyS83olfBtsVhYjPg2Ei3/D9D4Mvb7bFm9IaLJgYTFFuQCghrKQQFPiqJN320emjHxFowpIm1BkstnEU7lktH/XdXVBo8a6Uteiztw="